Six Numbers Missing From Your Startup Equity Offer


MacBook Pro on top of brown table

In 2025, more than 70% of vested stock options on Carta’s platform were never exercised when the employee left the company, whether the departure was a layoff or a choice. Those people earned the equity. They worked the months, cleared the cliff, watched the vesting schedule tick forward. Then they walked away from it, usually because they could not afford the exercise cost, or the window closed before they decided, or they finally did the math and realized the shares were worth less than the check.

Most of that math was available on the day they signed the offer. Nobody asked for it.

Product managers get asked to trade salary for equity more than most roles, especially at seed and Series A companies where the PM is one of the first ten or twenty hires. And product managers, of all people, should know better than to accept a bet without understanding its inputs. An offer letter that says “20,000 options” tells you almost nothing. It is a numerator with no denominator, a price with no market, and a payout with no conditions.

Most of my career was spent at a large telecom, where compensation was salary, a pension and a bonus formula you could read in a policy document. When I started doing fractional COO work with smaller companies, I sat on the other side of the table while founders wrote offers, and the gap surprised me. The founders were rarely hiding anything. Candidates simply did not ask, and an unasked question gets an unwritten answer.

Here are the six numbers to get before you sign. A good founder will give you all of them. A founder who will not is giving you a different kind of answer.

1. How many fully diluted shares exist?

This is the denominator, and without it your grant is meaningless. Twenty thousand options in a company with 2 million shares outstanding is 1%. The same grant in a company with 50 million shares is 0.04%.

Ask for the fully diluted count specifically. That number includes every issued share, every outstanding option, every warrant, every convertible note or SAFE that will turn into shares, and the unallocated option pool. Founders sometimes quote “issued and outstanding,” which is smaller and makes your slice look bigger.

Then ask what the next round will do to it. Carta’s analysis of 3,368 primary rounds found a median dilution of 20% at both seed and Series A, with the 75th percentile near 25%. If you join before the Series A and the company raises twice more before any exit, your 0.2% plausibly becomes something close to 0.13%. That is not a scandal. It is how venture financing works, and your model should assume it.

2. What is the strike price, and what is the latest 409A?

Your strike price is what you pay per share to exercise. It is usually set at the fair market value from the company’s most recent 409A valuation, an independent appraisal of the common stock.

The number that matters is the gap between that 409A price and what investors paid for preferred stock in the last round. Common stock is usually valued well below preferred, because preferred carries protections that common does not. That discount is fine for you while it lasts: it means a low exercise cost. But it also tells you the market already prices your shares as something other than the investors’ shares, which leads directly to question three.

Ask too when the last 409A was done. A stale valuation, or one that is about to be refreshed after a new round, can change your exercise cost meaningfully before your grant is even approved by the board.

3. What does the preference stack look like?

When a startup sells, investors with preferred stock get paid first. A 1x liquidation preference means an investor gets their money back before common shareholders see anything. Add up every round and you have the preference stack: the amount a buyer has to pay before your shares are worth a dollar.

Most rounds are 1x and non-participating, which is the cleaner structure. But not all. Carta reported that in Q1 2024, liquidation preferences above 1x appeared in 8% of new funding rounds, tied for the highest share that decade. A 2x preference on a $40 million round means the first $80 million of an exit goes to that investor.

You do not need to see the term sheets. Ask three things: total capital raised, whether any round carries a preference above 1x, and whether any preferred stock is participating (meaning it takes its preference and then also shares in what is left). Those three answers tell you the exit price below which your equity is worth zero.

4. How long do I have to exercise if I leave?

This is the question that decides whether the 70% figure applies to you.

The standard post-termination exercise period is 90 days, and Carta’s own guide notes that the vast majority of startups use it. The reason is tax law: incentive stock options keep their favorable treatment only if they are exercised within three months after employment ends, under Section 422(a)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code. Many companies simply matched their plan to that limit.

The result is a forced decision. You leave, and within three months you either write a check for the exercise cost (plus any tax owed on the spread) for shares you cannot sell, or you forfeit them. Combine that with the fact that, by Carta’s 2024 data, only about 4 in 10 startup employees stay long enough to finish their initial four-year grant, and most people face this decision with a partial grant and no liquidity.

Some companies have changed the rule. In March 2015, Pinterest gave employees with at least two years of tenure up to seven years after departure to exercise, converting the affected options from ISOs to non-qualified options to do it. Extensions also happen case by case: Carta found that companies extended the exercise window on 20% of options held by terminated employees in Q1 2023, a period full of layoffs.

Ask what the plan says, and ask whether the company has ever extended it. If the answer is 90 days with no exceptions, discount the grant accordingly. You are being offered something that may require a five-figure decision under a deadline.

5. Can I exercise early?

Some plans allow early exercise: you buy unvested shares at the strike price right away, and the company keeps a right to repurchase them if you leave before they vest. When the strike price is low, this can cost very little, and it starts the clock on long-term capital gains treatment.

The catch is the 83(b) election. If you early exercise, you generally need to file it with the IRS within 30 days of the share transfer, under Treasury Regulation 1.83-2, and there is no extension for missing it. Plenty of people have lost real money to a form that sat in a drawer for five weeks.

Early exercise is not right for everyone. You are putting cash into an illiquid, risky asset. But whether it is offered is a fair question, and the answer tells you something about how carefully the company set up its plan.

6. What happens to my vesting if the company is sold?

More than 90% of employees on Carta receive a four-year vest with a one-year cliff. That part rarely varies. What varies is acceleration.

Single-trigger acceleration vests some or all of your unvested shares when the company is acquired. Double-trigger acceleration requires two events: the acquisition and your termination (or a material demotion) within a set period afterward. Most employee grants have neither, which means an acquirer can let you go after the deal closes and your unvested shares disappear with you.

Double-trigger acceleration is a reasonable thing to ask for, particularly for a senior product hire whose role is likely to be duplicated in an acquiring company. Founders say no more often than yes. You learn something either way.

Turning six answers into one number

Once you have the answers, the model is short enough to build in a spreadsheet during the offer call.

Take a hypothetical: 20,000 options in a company with 10 million fully diluted shares, a $1.00 strike price and $60 million in 1x non-participating preferences. Your starting ownership is 0.2%. Assume two more rounds at 20% dilution each, and it falls to about 0.128%. Now assume the company sells for $200 million, and that the preferred holders convert to common (they would, at that price). Your stake is worth roughly $256,000, minus $20,000 to exercise, before tax.

Spread that over four years and it is about $59,000 a year, if you stay all four years, if the company sells, and if it sells for $200 million. Run it again at a $70 million exit and the preferred holders take their money first; you are working with whatever is left above $60 million, which might not cover the exercise cost. Run it a third time at zero, because most venture-backed startups do not return capital to common holders at all.

Then compare those scenarios to the salary you are giving up. If the company is asking you to take $30,000 a year less than market (a figure you can check against current product manager pay data), the equity has to clear that bar in a realistic outcome, not just the hopeful one.

Asking is part of the job

Candidates worry that these questions make them look difficult. In my experience the opposite is true. A product manager who asks for the fully diluted share count and the preference stack is showing exactly the skill the founder is hiring for: refusing to commit resources to a bet without knowing the odds.

If the numbers check out and you still want the role, you are in a much stronger position to negotiate the offer, because you can trade between cash and equity with your eyes open. And if the founder will not give you the denominator, you have learned the most important number of all.

Ty Sutherland

Ty Sutherland is the editor of Product Management Resources. With a quarter-century of product expertise under his belt, Ty is a seasoned veteran in the world of product management. A dedicated student of lean principles, he is driven by the ambition to transform organizations into Exponential Organizations (ExO) with a massive transformative purpose. Ty's passion isn't just limited to theory; he's an avid experimenter, always eager to try out a myriad of products and services. While he has a soft spot for tools that enhance the lives of product managers, his curiosity knows no bounds. If you're ever looking for him online, there's a good chance he's scouring his favorite site, Product Hunt, for the next big thing. Join Ty as he navigates the ever-evolving product landscape, sharing insights, reviews, and invaluable lessons from his vast experience.

Recent Posts